238 Pagosa St, Pagosa Springs, CO 81147
(970) 264-9348
Daily Menu
Holiday Menu OPEN 7 DAYS A WEEK 7AM TO 6PM!
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Home
  • About Us
    • About PBC
    • Sustainability
    • Media Mentions
    • Blog
  • Menu
    • Daily Menu
    • Monthly Specials
    • Bread Schedule
    • Holiday Specials
    • Catering
    • Sweets & Cakes
    • Sensitivity Menu
    • We Make U Bake
  • We are Foodies
    • Gingerbread House Contest
    • Sourdough Crock
    • Baking at Altitude
    • All Our Recipes
    • People We Love
  • Contact
    • Opportunities
  • Shop
  • Cart
    • Checkout
  • Log In

Handcrafted Baked Goods | Nourishing Simple Meals | Community Gathering Place

Coffee Shop Pagosa Springs CO Cafe

Holiday Specials

Thanksgiving Day 2026

Complete the form below or call 970-264-9348 to place your order by Sunday 11/22/2026        

Be sure to click submit if using the form

Pick up:  Wed. 11/25 7:00 am- 4 pm,  or Thanksgiving Day, 7 am–12 pm   

 

Thanksgiving Order Form

Order your Thanksgiving baked goods by Sunday 11/22/2026

Name(Required)
Pick up Date(Required)
PIck up Wednesday 11/25 from 7 am to 4 pm or Thanksgiving Day 11/26 from 7 am to noon
Phone(Required)
Traditional spiced pumpkin custard
Price: $28.00
With PCI, we'll make sure your pie will go to a family recovering from the recent floods. Please put 11/25/2026 if you are ordering only Pay it Forward pies.
Price: $28.00
Sweet and loaded with toasted pecans
Price: $32.00
Sweet and loaded with toasted pecans
Price: $32.00
Sweet & Tart with buttery vanilla crumb topping
Price: $29.00
Double crust, hand prepared Granny Smith apples
Price: $29.00
Just like the apple pie, with the extra tang and color of cranberries
Price: $29.00
An Adult Dessert – pumpkin sponge cake filled with rum cream, served with caramel custard sauce
Price: $20.00
An Adult Dessert – pumpkin sponge cake filled with rum cream, served with caramel custard sauce
Price: $40.00
Take “N Bake for your own pie filling
Price: $8.80
Our popular Pumpkin Muffins baked in a small loaf, 14 oz
Price: $9.50
A dozen of our buttery crispy shortbread cookies
Price: $15.00
A half dozen of our traditional Challah, in 2 oz rolls
Price: $8.25
Our seasonal sourdough loaf: pumpkin puree, local whole wheat, local whole rye, spiced with cinnamon, cloves & ginger, and studded with pumpkin seeds. 2 # loaf
Price: $12.00
Based on our Rye Sourdough starter, with Mountain Mama whole rye and whole wheat. A flavorful daily loaf.
Price: $7.35
Based on our Rye Sourdough starter, with Mountain Mama whole rye and whole wheat. A flavorful daily loaf.
Price: $10.25
Based on our Wheat Sourdough Starter, with olive oil & rosemary.
Price: $7.35
Based on our Wheat Sourdough Starter, with olive oil & rosemary.
Price: $10.25

 

 

 

 

 

Primary Sidebar

September 2022 Closed Monday through Thursday

9/12 through 9/15 and 9/19 through 22

Regular hours:

Open 6 days a week!

Wednesday through Monday 7 am to 2 pm

Closed Tuesdays

Call (970) 264-9348 to order

  • TripAdvisor

 

  • TripAdvisor

Recent Posts

  • December Newsletter
  • Construction Parking
  • Chamber Business Spotlight

Recent Recipes

  • Pumpkin Muffins, Gluten Free
  • Strawberry or Raspberry Rhubarb Pie Filling
  • PBC Green Chile Chicken Stew
  • Carrot Cake Muffins
  • Pagosa Baking Company Shortbread

Footer

About Us:

Located at 238 Pagosa St, Pagosa Springs, CO 81147, Pagosa Baking Company is dedicated to creating and sharing handcrafted baked goods, nourishing meals and celebratory fare utilizing locally sourced organic ingredients, and so much more! Read on ...

Newsletter Signup

connect with us:

COPYRIGHT © 2006–2026 PAGOSA BAKING COMPANY. All Rights Reserved.